Bookkeeping for Claude, ChatGPT and other AI apps.

Contractor Or Employee?

How the CRA decides if a worker is an employee or a self-employed contractor, what a wrong call costs, and how to keep contractor totals ready.

Payroll Updated Facts Checked

What It Is

Every person you pay to work for your business is either an employee or a self-employed contractor. An employee works under a “contract of service.” You run payroll for them, withhold CPP, EI and income tax, and issue a T4. A contractor works under a “contract for services.” They are in business for themselves, they invoice you, and they handle their own tax. The label you choose does not decide it. The CRA looks at the real relationship, and if it disagrees with you, the payroll you skipped can come back as your bill.

Key Rules

  • Two steps outside Quebec. The CRA’s guide RC4110 first asks what you and the worker intended. Then it tests that intent against the real working relationship.
  • Intent is not enough on its own. The CRA says all the facts, including the actual terms and conditions, decide a worker’s status, not just the intention.
  • The six factors the CRA weighs:
    • Control. The CRA says it is the right to control the work that matters, not whether you actually use it.
    • Tools and equipment. A worker who invests heavily in their own tools looks self-employed. An employee is usually given tools or reimbursed.
    • Subcontracting and helpers. A contractor can hire helpers or send someone else. An employee cannot.
    • Financial risk. A contractor carries ongoing costs and can lose money. An employee has few unreimbursed expenses.
    • Investment and management. A contractor puts capital into the business and makes business decisions.
    • Opportunity for profit. The CRA says employees normally do not have the chance of a profit or the risk of a loss.
  • Quebec uses a different test. It is a three-step approach under the Civil Code, and the key question is whether there is a relationship of subordination.
  • What changes for an employee. You deduct and remit CPP and, for insurable employment, EI, and you pay the employer share of both. A self-employed worker pays both halves of CPP on their own return and only pays EI if they opt in.
  • Asking for a ruling. Form CPT1 requests a CPP and EI ruling. It is due by June 29 of the following year.
  • Penalties for not deducting. If the CRA decides a worker was an employee, the T4001 says it can assess a penalty of 10% of the CPP, EI and income tax you did not deduct, and 20% for a repeat failure made knowingly or through gross negligence.
  • Reporting contractor fees. Box 048 of the T4A is for fees paid for services, without GST/HST. The CRA currently is not assessing penalties tied to box 048, except under its policy for the trucking industry.

A Worked Example

Saltbox Bakery is a made-up bakery. It hires Riley to run its social media for $40,000 a year. Riley works set hours the bakery chooses, uses the bakery’s laptop and accounts, cannot send anyone else in her place, and has no business expenses. The bakery calls her a contractor and pays her invoices.

Here is what the bakery would owe for 2026 if Riley were on payroll instead:

  • Employer CPP: ($40,000 − $3,500) × 5.95% = $36,500 × 5.95% = $2,171.75
  • Employer EI: $40,000 × 1.63% × 1.4 = $40,000 × 2.282% = $912.80
  • Employer cost on top of pay: $2,171.75 + $912.80 = $3,084.55

Riley’s own share, which the bakery should have withheld, would be $2,171.75 of CPP and $40,000 × 1.63% = $652.00 of EI, or $2,823.75, plus her income tax.

Looking at the six factors, the bakery controls her hours and tools, she takes no financial risk, and she can’t subcontract. If the CRA reviews it and finds an employment relationship, the bakery has the missed CPP and EI to sort out, and the CRA can add a penalty of 10% of what it failed to deduct. On the CPP and EI alone, that penalty is $2,823.75 × 10% = $282.38, before income tax and interest.

Now compare Morgan, a photographer the bakery books twice a year. Morgan uses her own gear, sets her own price, works for many clients and sends an invoice with her GST/HST number. That looks like a business relationship.

Common Mistakes

  • Relying on the contract title. Calling someone a contractor does not make them one if the work looks like a job.
  • Treating a long-term, full-time role as a contract. A single “client” who sets your hours and supplies your tools is a warning sign.
  • Forgetting Quebec is different. Workers in Quebec are assessed under a different test.
  • Not tracking contractor payments by person. At year-end you need a total per contractor, before GST/HST, to report fees for services.
  • Waiting for a CRA review. If you are unsure, ask your accountant early or request a ruling with Form CPT1.

How Solarium Handles It

Solarium does not decide who is an employee. That call belongs to you, your accountant and, if needed, the CRA. What Solarium does is keep contractor payments clean and easy to total:

  • Every bill, e-transfer or card payment to a contractor comes into Solarium from your bank feed, or from the bill you email or text in. Solarium learns each vendor’s usual category, so repeat payments are quicker to review.
  • The Vendors report in Solarium shows what you paid each vendor by month or quarter. Amounts are before sales tax, which matches how box 048 asks for fees. Click any vendor to see every payment behind the total.
  • Ask your AI in Claude or ChatGPT, connected to Solarium, “How much did we pay each contractor in 2026?” and it pulls the same numbers from your books, ready to send to your accountant.

If you do move someone onto payroll, Solarium already has Wages & Salaries and Payroll Liabilities accounts set up. See pricing for plans, or let our Done For You team keep the books for you.

Common Questions

Does A Contract That Says Independent Contractor Settle It? +

No. The CRA looks at what the parties intended, then checks whether the real working relationship matches. All the facts decide the worker's status, not just the wording of the contract.

How Do I Get An Official Answer From The CRA? +

You or the worker can ask the CRA for a CPP and EI ruling using Form CPT1. The CRA's guide says the request is due by June 29 of the year after the year in question.

Do I Issue A Slip To A Contractor? +

Fees for services can be reported in box 048 of a T4A slip. The CRA says it is generally not assessing penalties for box 048 right now, except under its trucking policy, so ask your accountant what to file for your contractors.

Can Solarium Tell Me What I Paid Each Contractor? +

Yes. Solarium's Vendors report shows what you spent with each vendor by month or quarter, before sales tax, and you can click through to every payment.

Sources

Solarium checks every rate, threshold and deadline in this entry against the official sources above. This is general information. Solarium and Maple Ventures Core Inc. do not provide tax advice for your situation.

Let Solarium Keep Your Books

Connect your bank, text your receipts, and Solarium sorts the GST/HST for you. Start free with self-serve, or let the Solarium team close your books daily.